2. Timber Lodge
If you really want to splurge, rent out this luxurious three-story cabin on remote Orcas Island. Take a romantic walk around the private grounds (which include a waterfall) or catch a Niners game in the home theater that boasts leather seats and a 105-inch screen. Nothing quite like taking over someone else's turf, right?
445 Lindsay Way, Eastsound (800-418-7990)